Skip to Content

Sugar Cream Pie

 

Sweet custard, flaky crust, warm flavors of vanilla and nutmeg…this sugar cream pie is the perfect holiday recipe for your sweet tooth!

Sugar cream pie

This wonderful sugar cream pie recipe originally appeared on the blog for the 2013 holiday season. Well, seven years have gone by, we’ve remade and rephotographed this delightful dessert for you, and updated the post and recipe card to boot! If you didn’t take notice of this recipe way back then, we’d encourage you to add it to your holiday menu this time around!

Sooo, this pie. I’ve been thinking, dreaming, and fantasizing about this pie since last year. LAST YEAR PEOPLE! It all started when I was 8 1/2 months pregnant and I got the Thanksgiving issue of The Food Network Magazine in the mail. I was flipping through it a few weeks before Thanksgiving and came across THIS PIE. OMG! I was gone at the first mention of the word sugar. I knew I had to make it.  But ya know, being so pregnant was preventing me from actually wanting to *gasp* bake…so I held off. Until last week. sugar cream pie recipe

Believe it or not, I had never even heard of this pie until I read the recipe in the magazine. Apparently, this pie dates back to the 1800’s when the Quakers would bake it up because it used a lot of staples they already had on hand, like cream and sugar. I hear this pie is pretty popular in Indiana, too. Are any of my readers from Indiana? Is this little fact true?

I’m quite giddy over this pie because not only is it super easy – all you do is mix the ingredients together and throw it into a pie crust and then bake it – but it tastes amazing and is the perfect pie to serve along with your Thanksgiving dinner. Make it ahead of time and wow your guests with this sweet little unexpected surprise of a dessert!sugar cream pie with nutmeg and vanilla

 
Sugar Cream Pie

Sugar Cream Pie

Yield: 8
Prep Time: 35 minutes
Cook Time: 1 hour 5 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour 40 minutes

Sweet custard, flaky crust, warm flavors of vanilla and nutmeg...this sugar cream pie is the perfect holiday recipe for your sweet tooth!

Ingredients

  • 19 inch pie crust (premade or your favorite recipe)
  • 2 cups heavy whipping cream
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1/4 cup cornstarch
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
  • 2 tbsp unsalted butter, cut into 1/2 inch pieces
  • 1/8 tsp ground nutmeg
  • 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Prepare the pie crust and fit it into your 9-inch pie plate, trim and crimp the edges with your fingers. Pierce the bottom with a fork and bake for 10-12 minutes.
  2. In a medium-sized saucepan, whisk the heavy whipping cream, sugar, cornstarch, vanilla, cinnamon and nutmeg over medium-low heat, until the mixture is thickened and bubbling. This takes about 10 minutes. Make sure you whisk continuously, especially towards the end as the mixture thickens to prevent burning on the bottom of the saucepan.
  3. Add the butter and whisk until melted and mixture boils for another minute or two.
  4. Pour the filling into the prepared and cooled pie crust and place on on a baking sheet and place in oven. Bake for 10-15 minutes or until you see bubbling towards the edge of the crust.
  5. Carefully remove hot pie from oven and allow to cool on a wire rack for one hour. Cover with plastic wrap and chill in the refrigerator for 8 hours before serving.
  6. Sprinkle lightly with cinnamon and serve. Pie keeps in the fridge for up to one week. This is an easy make-ahead pie for the holidays.

Notes

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 8 Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 452Total Fat: 30gSaturated Fat: 17gTrans Fat: 1gUnsaturated Fat: 11gCholesterol: 75mgSodium: 107mgCarbohydrates: 43gFiber: 1gSugar: 28gProtein: 4g

Nutrition information isn’t always accurate.

Cory

Monday 7th of December 2015

I am a born Hoosier living in San Francisco (yes, the "official" pie of Indiana is infact the Sugar Cream) I have been searching everywhere for a Sugar Cream pie and when I ask at bakeries I even blank stares. Finally I've decided that I am going to have to make one myself...this recipe is getting made this week!!

Chelsia Rief

Tuesday 8th of December 2015

I love love love this pie, but I had never heard of it either until I found it. But once I tasted it, it was love at first bite. Let me know how it turns out for you :)

eRecipe

Monday 18th of November 2013

I'd like to invite you to join our site www.erecipe.com . I really enjoy your blog and recipes and I think the over 8,000 unique daily visitors to eRecipe will too. By joining eRecipe, we will provide the Nutrition Facts for every recipe you post in which you could customize and add to your blog. Viewers need and love to know the nutritional facts. Its a free service that we offer to blogs and recipes we really love. It looks professional and your members will love it.Simply visit www.erecipe.com or contact me at [email protected] We look forward having you in our network!

Dina

Sunday 17th of November 2013

I am a cream fanatic. this looks like something I would love!

Karen @ The Food Charlatan

Friday 15th of November 2013

This looks so awesome!! I am not from Indiana, but we lived there for 2 years for grad school, and that was the first place I'd heard of it. But I've still never made it, lame me! It looks so easy, I will have to try it. Pinned!

Chels/Catz in the Kitchen

Saturday 16th of November 2013

Thanks, Karen! You definitely need to make this pie! It is super easy. I'm definitely going to make it for Thanksgiving this year at my house.

Nancy

Friday 15th of November 2013

This is so close to my grandmother's recipe! We always thought of sugar cream pies being an "Indiana thing", but our home town of Richmond has a large Quaker population and even a Quaker college, so that association makes sense.

Chels/Catz in the Kitchen

Saturday 16th of November 2013

It is so good Nancy! How is your recipe slightly different?

Skip to Recipe