Skip to Content

Sweet Cream Pancakes

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.There’s a very simple explanation for why we sought out, tested, fell in love with, and finally shared this recipe. It has a lot to do with Black Bear Diner. See, historically, we would go out to Black Bear when visiting relatives in California, whether that was Chels’ folks in the Redding area, or mine down in LA. They’ve got great food, great service, and a fun, homey atmosphere that reminds you of a classic diner (minus some of the grease and health code concerns…). I should probably make it clear at this point – this post isn’t sponsored by or affiliated with anyone, including Black Bear Diner – we’re just fans!

We all looked forward to our occasional visits to the California Black Bear locations, and lo and behold, a couple of years ago, we got the welcome news that they were expanding to the Pacific Northwest, including a location about half an hour from our humble abode here in the Willamette Valley! (Apparently they’re as far east as Missouri now.) Naturally, we’ve been going more often since then, and we’ve discovered something in the process…we love sweet cream pancakes

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.

We’ve always (Chels especially) had a soft spot for a classic breakfast of pancakes (or hotcakes, or flapjacks, or whatever you want to call them). We’ve got about ten pancake recipes on the blog at this point (though, admittedly the pictures are only presently in about four of them – some reshoots to be done there!). Zucchini pancakes? Pumpkin pancakes? German pancakes? Whole wheat pancakes? We’ve got you covered. But sweet cream pancakes? They may be classic, they may be simple, maybe some of you grew up with them, but for us…sweet cream pancakes were a revelation, and we craved them. 

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.

It’s kind of hard to describe what makes them so special. It’s really the sheer classicness (not a word) of them. They look and feel and taste the way you dream about pancakes…you know, because, everyone dreams about pancakes, don’t they? Right…? Okay, I digress. At any rate, they are fluffy and light, with just a touch of sugar and vanilla, and, as the name implies, just a hint of creaminess in each bite. They’re like a traditional, classic buttermilk pancake…but with more…pancakeness (also not a word). 

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.

Obviously, Black Bear Diner is not likely to be interested in giving away their wonderful sweet cream pancakes recipe, so we did some hunting and testing, looking for one that was both easy to make and as close to our new favorites as possible. We eventually found this delightful recipe over at the Rocky Mountain Woman’s blog, doubled it, and never looked back. We’re hooked, and they are now a regular feature on our family breakfast table. Try them, and I bet they will be for you, too. 

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.

Sweet Cream Pancakes

Yield: 20-30 pancakes
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 45 minutes

Fluffy & light, with a touch of sugar, vanilla, & creaminess in each bite, these sweet cream pancakes are a level up from traditional buttermilk flapjacks.

Ingredients

  • 6 eggs
  • 2 cups low fat milk
  • 2 cups fat free half and half
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 1 tbsp + 1 tsp baking powder
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 4 cups flour
  • 3 tbsp vanilla

Instructions

  1. Mix dry ingredients (sugar, baking powder, salt, flour) together in large bowl.
  2. Separate eggs, setting aside the whites. Thoroughly mix wet ingredients (egg yolks, milk, half and half, vanilla) in another large bowl.
  3. Pour wet ingredients into dry ingredients, whisking gently until the mixture just comes together.
  4. Using a stand mixer (or a hand mixer, if necessary), beat egg whites until they form soft peaks, then gently fold into the batter.
  5. Heat a griddle or skillet to medium high heat, and coat with vegetable oil or butter (according to preference - butter gives a sweeter taste, while oil gives crispier edges). Scoop 1/3 cup of batter into the pan or onto the skillet for each pancake, and cook until bottom is golden brown. Flip and cook until opposite side is golden brown as well.
  6. Preferably, serve each batch of pancakes immediately as they come off the skillet or griddle. If necessary, pancakes may be kept warm in an oven at 200 degrees. Serve with butter and real maple syrup. Refrigerate leftovers (if you're lucky enough to have any!).

Notes

Doubled and very slightly modified from original recipe by The Rocky Mountain Woman.

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 8 Serving Size: 3
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 404Total Fat: 6gSaturated Fat: 2gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 3gCholesterol: 146mgSodium: 493mgCarbohydrates: 70gFiber: 2gSugar: 20gProtein: 15g

Weekly Menu | Catz in the Kitchen | catzinthekitchen.com | #mealplan
Weekly Menu for the Week of Jan 21
← Read Last Post
Let your pantry come to your rescue with this easy minestrone chicken noodle soup - this
"Pantry to the Rescue" Minestrone Chicken Noodle Soup
Read Next Post →

Hazel

Saturday 10th of October 2020

I always thought black bears pancakes had some kind of powdered sugar in them. It seems they dissolve in your mouth. I didn't expect these recipes to pull it off. But I haven't tried it yet, who knows. But I'll give it a go. Buttermilk has worked wonders for me though...

Summer

Monday 3rd of June 2019

I work for Black Bear and their pancakes are the best!!! I will admit that!!!

Mara

Sunday 7th of June 2020

Do these match them? I am literally obsessed and tried another recipe that was almost the same except quantity of baking powered and I was disappointed 🙁

Chelsia Rief

Tuesday 4th of June 2019

It's been too long since we've been to Black Bear. I'm thinking we need to fix that so I can have their pancakes again. ;)

Justin Gantt

Friday 5th of April 2019

Ok, I'm a fan of pancakes. I live in Michigan and some of the places that have pretty good pancakes are Cracker Barrel and also OHOP (Original House of Pancakes) A co-worker told me about the pancakes from Black Bear and of course there none in the Midwest. I want to try this recipe, but it's only for me and maybe my girlfriend. Can you create the recipe for 1-2 people?

Tiffini

Saturday 14th of November 2020

There is a Black Bear in St. Charles Missouri if you’re ever looking for the best pancakes and a roadtrip!

Joshua Rief

Friday 5th of April 2019

IHOP I know, but this OHOP is new to me...we do have Cracker Barrel, but I'll admit I've never tried their pancakes! Will have to do so. As for shrinking the recipe down, you can definitely do that. If I were you, I would halve it. It should make 10-15 pancakes, and if you have a few left over...they heat up great!

Buzzyberry

Friday 25th of January 2019

Hi there,that’s a wonderful collection of recipes. You can submit your recipe links with us at https://buzzyberry.com/ Buzzyberry is a collection of articles,food,recipes and much more Visit our site and discover more.

Skip to Recipe
shares